The Pricing Ceiling That’s Holding You Back
If you’ve been grinding to sell $99/month coaching plans and still feel like you’re stuck financially, you’re not alone. Many personal trainers and fitness professionals start with low-ticket offerings thinking it will be easier to sell — and for a while, it works. But eventually, most realize they’re running on a treadmill of churn. They’re constantly replacing clients, stretching their time thin, and struggling to build a truly sustainable business.
The reality? Selling more low-priced offers doesn’t always lead to more income — or more impact. It often leads to burnout.
That’s why a growing number of coaches are shifting their model. Instead of chasing volume, they’re selling high-ticket coaching programs priced at $500, $999, or even $2,000+. These coaches are still helping clients transform, but they’re doing it with fewer clients, more structure, and higher margins.
You might be wondering: Is it really possible to sell a $1,000+ fitness program? The answer is yes — and this guide will show you how.
1. Why High-Ticket Is the Future for Coaches
Let’s break down the differences between low-ticket and high-ticket coaching:
Low-ticket coaching (under $200/month):
- Requires a large number of clients to hit income goals
- Often attracts less committed clients
- Leads to more admin, messaging, and session delivery
- Has high churn (clients leave quickly)
- Makes it hard to provide truly individualized service
High-ticket coaching ($500–$2,000+ per package or month):
- Attracts more serious, results-driven clients
- Requires fewer clients to meet or exceed income goals
- Allows you to deliver deeper transformation with more structure and accountability
- Builds stronger, longer-lasting relationships
- Encourages more engagement and better results
This isn’t just a pricing tactic — it’s a fundamental shift in how coaches view the value of their service.
Fitness coaching is no longer about “access” — it’s about outcomes. People don’t just want another workout plan. They want to feel better in their body. Build confidence. Gain strength. Lose the weight they’ve struggled with for years. And they’re willing to pay more to get those results — especially if you have a clear path to get them there.
2. What’s Really Stopping You from Charging More
The biggest barrier to charging premium prices isn’t your audience — it’s your mindset.
Here are three common mindset blocks that keep coaches undercharging:
1. Imposter Syndrome
“I’m not experienced enough to charge more.”
Even seasoned coaches feel this. But the truth is, if you’ve helped people get results, you’ve already proven your value. High-ticket coaching isn’t about being the best in the world — it’s about clearly communicating how you help people solve a specific problem.
2. Fear of Rejection
“What if people say no?”
Not everyone will say yes — and that’s okay. High-ticket sales are about alignment, not volume. You’re not trying to sell to everyone. You’re looking for the right people who see the value and are ready to invest.
3. Misunderstanding Value
“I’m just providing workouts and check-ins — is that really worth $999?”
This is a major mindset shift. People don’t pay for time or tasks. They pay for transformation. If your coaching helps someone lose 20 pounds, build muscle, feel confident, or avoid surgery — that’s extremely valuable.
Reframe it this way: You’re not charging for minutes. You’re charging for results, and the life-changing impact those results create.
3. What Makes a High-Ticket Offer “Worth It”
High-ticket programs work because they’re positioned differently. It’s not just about more support — it’s about creating a container that leads to real, lasting change.
Here’s what every high-ticket offer needs:
- A Clear Outcome
People don’t buy coaching — they buy the result. “Lose 10kg in 90 days,” “Finally get your first pull-up,” “Train for your first half marathon.” You need a crystal-clear promise so your program feels outcome-driven.
- A Defined Framework
Your method matters. Package your unique way of delivering results into a signature process or system. This might be a three-phase program (e.g., Assess – Train – Sustain), or a weekly breakdown of how clients move toward their goal.
- Added Support
To justify premium pricing, your clients should get more than just workouts. Consider:
- Weekly or bi-weekly check-ins
- Nutrition guidance or accountability
- Community via group messaging
- Progress tracking through TrueCoach
- Mindset coaching or habit support
- Professional Presentation
How you package your offer influences how it’s perceived. Naming your program (“The Body Breakthrough Blueprint” vs. “Online Coaching”) increases authority. A branded sales page, testimonials, and strong visuals all boost credibility.
The bottom line: your program should feel like an all-in-one solution, not a piecemeal service.
4. Start Selling with Confidence: The 3-Sale Shift
Most coaches think selling high-ticket requires hard selling or manipulative tactics. Not true. It’s actually about having better conversations, asking better questions, and showing how your program solves a real problem.
Here’s what needs to shift:
1. Sell the Transformation, Not the Time
Instead of listing the features of your program (4 workouts/week, biweekly calls, etc.), focus on the transformation it delivers.
“This program helps busy professionals build strength and drop 10lbs without sacrificing their weekends.”
2. Qualify Before You Pitch
Don’t pitch your program to everyone. Use application forms, surveys, or DMs to filter for people who are truly ready. Ask about their goals, current struggles, and what they’ve tried before. This makes your sales process smoother and more aligned.
3. Sell Through Conversations
High-ticket sales aren’t made on a checkout page. They’re made in conversations. Whether through DMs, video calls, or voice notes — you’re helping someone make a life-changing decision. That requires trust, clarity, and empathy.
You don’t need to be pushy. You just need to clearly show that your program can help them get where they want to go — and that you’re the right coach to guide them.
Conclusion: Your Next Step
If you’re still reading, chances are you’re ready to stop spinning your wheels with low-ticket offers and start charging what you’re worth. High-ticket coaching isn’t just for elite trainers or influencers. It’s for any coach who can confidently deliver results, cares about their clients, and wants to build a sustainable business.
Making the leap is about strategy, mindset, and execution — and you don’t have to figure it out alone.
Want a deeper roadmap?
Download our free guide: How to Sell High-Ticket Coaching Programs.
It’s packed with step-by-step strategies, pricing frameworks, and templates to help you confidently create and sell your first premium program.
Get your copy today — it’s free for a limited time.
Recommended Resources For You
Resource
The Ultimate Business Planner for Coaches & Personal Trainers
Author: Bobby O’Connell
The TrueCoach Business Planner is your all-in-one solution to streamline your workflow, maximize productivity, and grow your business without the stress of juggling multiple tools. Whether you’re creating your schedule, planning social media content, or managing finances, this planner ensures everything is in one place, giving you more time to focus on what truly matters—your clients and business growth.
Resource
2025 Personal Trainer Trends & Strategies Report
Author: Bobby O’Connell
Marketing is one of the most critical tools for growing any business, but there’s no one size fits all strategy. Do you know how well your current strategy is doing? And what should you do to prepare for the new year?
Resource
30-Day Client Magnet Blueprint
Author: Bobby O’Connell
This free guide includes: Ready to take your fitness business to the next level? Download this guide now to get started! Why Choose This Ebook The reason why most personal trainers only last 5-7 years in the industry is the fact that they are unable to make a regular income due to a lack of […]
Sign-Up for Our Newsletter
Author: Bobby O'Connell FRSA CSM
-
First published: June 17 2025
Written by: Bobby O'Connell